On the early morning of March 18, 1990, shortly after St. Patrick's Day celebrations, two men dressed as Boston police officers arrived at the Isabella Stewart Gardner Museum in Boston, Massachusetts. Security guard Richard Abath buzzed them inside, believing they were investigating a disturbance. Within minutes, the men handcuffed and duct-taped both guards—Abath and 25-year-old Randy Hestand—to an electrical box. "Gentlemen, this is a robbery," one thief declared.

What followed was a meticulously planned heist. The thieves disabled CCTV cameras and removed the alarm motion sensor printout. Spending more than an hour inside the museum, they carefully cut 13 artworks from their frames without damaging the paintings themselves. The haul included masterpieces by Rembrandt, Vermeer, and Manet, plus five Degas sketches, an ancient Chinese vase, and a Napoleonic eagle finial. The guards remained captive, their eyes and chins wrapped in duct tape, until police arrived at 8:15 AM.

#### The Stolen Treasures

The theft targeted some of the world's most prized paintings. Rembrandt's *The Storm on the Sea of Galilee*—his only seascape—disappeared along with his portrait *A Lady and Gentleman in Black*. Johannes Vermeer's *The Concert* vanished from the walls, as did Édouard Manet's *Chez Tortoni*. Five Degas works, including *Leaving the Paddock*, were also taken. Today, empty frames remain on the museum's walls as permanent monuments to the crime. Valued at $200 million in 1990, the stolen collection is now estimated at $500–600 million.

#### Why Security Failed

The Gardner Museum's vulnerability wasn't accidental. Despite the FBI foiling a robbery plot against the institution in the 1980s by local criminals, the museum installed no security cameras or enhanced precautions. The institution had long been known for its minimal security infrastructure—a decision that made the 1990 heist possible.

#### The Investigation and Suspects

More than three decades later, the case remains unsolved. Early investigations pointed to figures with Boston Mafia ties. Bobby Donati emerged as a suspected mastermind; he was murdered in 1991, his body discovered stabbed in a car trunk after his home had been ransacked. Art thief Myles Connor Jr. implicated Donati and David Houghton as the architects of the heist, suggesting they planned to use the stolen artworks as leverage against criminal indictments. Gangster Vincent Ferrara later claimed Donati orchestrated the robbery to negotiate his release from jail—but was killed before negotiations could begin.

Carmello Merlino, another figure with Mafia connections, was also named as a suspect. Despite these leads, no arrests have resulted in convictions.

The museum offered a $10 million reward for the return of the artworks, but no breakthrough came. The paintings remain missing, their whereabouts unknown.

#### Bringing the Story to Screen

In April 2021, Netflix released *This Is a Robbery: The World's Biggest Art Heist*, a four-part documentary series directed by Colin Barnicle. Produced over seven years beginning in 2014, the series examines the heist's mechanics, explores the suspects, and investigates the Mafia connection theories that have long captivated investigators and art world observers.

The Gardner Museum theft endures as a singular crime in art history—a brazen daylight robbery executed with precision, leaving behind questions that remain unanswered and masterpieces that have never been recovered.

#### Sources

https://thermtide.com/14164/popular/this-is-a-robbery-an-in-depth-look-at-infamous-art-heist/

https://www.esquire.com/uk/culture/tv/a36050245/this-is-a-robbery-netflix-true-story/

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/This_Is_a_Robbery

https://www.dontdiewondering.com/this-is-a-robbery-the-greatest-unsolved-art-heist-in-history/

https://www.goodmorningamerica.com/news/story/inside-worlds-largest-art-heist-500m-paintings-stolen-132397211